Profile image

challenge results #4

52.8k Astro12  3.0 years ago

Good morning/afternoon/evening (or whatever). Okay, forget it. I finally finished the tests and am ready to give you the results. Awards are on their way, so wait.

I apologize for doing this for a long time. There were really a lot of applications.

Points were awarded based on the results of these tests. My feelings from the flight were the basis of the assessments.

Thanks to everyone who took part, and don't be discouraged if you didn't take a prize. my opinion is subjective and it may not coincide with yours.

The rewards may be a little delayed, but remember that the consolation prize was given out upon enrollment (therefore winning 10 UPVOTE = 1 from the beginning, + 9 UPVOTE later)

The planes are arranged in ascending order of score. If two planes receive the same number of points, they are placed in the order in which they were submitted.

As the application was really a lot, I could not properly monitor the quality of translation, so sometimes it is possible full of nonsense in the comments to the builds. Also, I may have mixed up the pictures (although I tried to avoid that.) In general, if you notice that I screwed up, tell me about it in the comments.

PLEASE PAY ATTENTION

IF YOU CHANGE THE NAME AFTER SUBMITTING THE APPLICATION, THEN THE OLD NICK WILL BE SPECIFIED IN THE RESULTS AND TAGS


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/2s4nkM/EW-UD
@KalebsStuff.
Appearance: 5/30 points. (badly.)
The plane performs its functions: 5/20 points. (No, it hardly flies.)
Flight characteristics: 3/20 points. (straight line... )
Cool features: x/25 points. (no)
Description : 4/25 points. (not much)

Total : 17/120
(did you test it at all?)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/4z02c7/my-unusual-plane-challenge-plane
@MrPringles
Appearance: 10/30 points. (you can do better, you know.)
The plane performs its functions: 2/20 points. (it's not a plane, it's not a guided missile.)
Flight characteristics: 5/20 points. (flies only in a straight line)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (None)
Description : 2/25 points. (empty almost)

Total : 19/120
(try harder)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/8oseon/BFJ-x
@Blockmanufacturer0228
Appearance: 10/30 points. (hard).
The plane performs its functions: 5/20 points. (no control)
Flight characteristics: 2/20 points. (plane is VERY unstable)
Cool features: 1/25 points. (Droptanks)
Description : 2/25 points. (No, bro, no.)

Total : 20/120
(instability is our everything.)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/7660Sd/Gk-9-small-boi
@Hobbeskazee614
(-5 points (rule 1) )
Appearance: 5/30 points. (I can build this in a minute)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (will not do much)
Flight characteristics: 10/20 points. (flies well)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (no)
Description : 2/25 points. (you could have written more)

Total : 22/120
(frankly weak)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/oxoa62/Pacific-A-55-Sandshark
@PacificRepublic.
Appearance: 6/30 points. (no, man, no. )
The plane performs its functions: 2/20 points. (it doesn't take off. Don't ask it to do anything.)
Flight characteristics: 0/20 points. (Corkscrew and stall are his flight characteristics.)
Cool features: 0/25 points. No.
Description: 15/25 points. (detailed description)

Total : 23/120
(pulled from the bottom on the description. As you can see, it is useful. )


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/rQx9Uv/Lankaric-A-1-Stork
@Designdude1
Appearance: 10/30 points. (the worst part is that it flies)
The plane performs its functions: 5/20 points. (I do not know what they are)
Flight characteristics: 5/20 points. (desperately lacking power and tight controls.)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (no)
Description : 4/25 points. (like this commercial)

Total : 24/120
(it gives me a panic attack)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/25M5wx/JC-10-Experimental-Canard-Sailfish
@Ruskiwaffle1991
Appearance: 10/30 points. (looks, to put it bluntly, not very good)
The plane performs its functions: 5/20 points. (for a modern fighter - very bad)
Flight characteristics: 5/20 points. (it flies, but slowly and very poorly maneuvering, and poorly gaining altitude. Also, there is no trimmer. )
Cool features: 0/25 points. (missing)
Description : 5/25 points. (it has a story, but I would like to see something about the control)

Total : 25/120
(work on Maneuverability)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/Bqt1hW/P-193
@Wildcat1941
Appearance: 10/30 points. (horror)
The plane performs its functions: 5/20 points. (One bomb and two machine guns? )
Flight characteristics: 10/20 points. (Barely flies)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (None)
Description : 2/25 points. (not much, to be honest)

Total : 27/120
(I have seen better)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/5617U4/Odd-plane-with-mortars
@Cobra63
Appearance: 10/30 points. (looks cerebral)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (not bad as a ground attack aircraft, but terrible as a fighter)
Flight characteristics: 8/20 points. (Not bad, it lacks stability and pitch. )
Cool features: 0/25 points. (None)
Description : 1/25 points. (almost nothing)

Total : 29/120
(Plane does not take off well. Will redesign landing gear.)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/osg74z/DRM-5
@Sorren
Appearance: 10/30 points. (not terrible, but looks bad)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (can do something)
Flight characteristics: 5/20 points. (flies badly)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (none)
Description : 4/25 points. (few)

Total : 29/120
(but not the worst for today)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/wMY2nL/Razor-1000
@Maximum1
Appearance: 10/30 points. (not great)
The plane performs its functions: 5/20 points. (bad fighter)
Flight Characteristics: 10/20 points. (Seems to fly)
Cool features: 0/25 points. No.
Description : 4/25 points. (empty and no control explained)

Total : 29/120
(strange form)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/j3yi8r/Reconnaissance-aircraft
@Flight13airforse
Appearance: 10/30 points. (angular).
Airplane performs its function: 10/20 points. (bad scout)
Flight performance: 10/20 points. (flies)
Cool performance: 0/25 points. (none)
Description : 0/25 points. (none)

Total : 30/120
(right angles!)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/hImKP4/BSA-1M-Scavenger
@BigDoot
Appearance: 10/30 points. (so-so, to be honest)
The plane performs its functions: 3/20 points. (An assault plane of that size and armament? Is that a joke? )
Flight characteristics: 15/20 points. (It flies well.)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (None)
Description : 3/25 points. (not much)

Total : 31/120
(I've seen better ones today. )


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/iH2HRb/Republic-XP-35-Karambit
@SturerEmil
Appearance: 10/30 points. (strange, but possible)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (Not a fighter)
Flight characteristics: 10/20 points. (it flies, but does not steer well)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (None)
Description : 4/25 points. (with history)

Total : 34/120
(oh my, how small it is).


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/BO74vp/Cursed-Plane
@Ihatenames
Appearance: 15/30 points. (simple)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (the plane is difficult to fly)
Flight characteristics: 5/20 points. (has difficulty staying in the air)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (None)
Description : 5/25 points. (easy)

Total : 35/120
(I have seen this somewhere)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/EJ7rPv/Eversoft
@NavalGunnery
Appearance: 10/30 points. (simple. Very.)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (As a transport it is not bad.)
Flight characteristics: 10/20 points. (suddenly, it flies. It's even maneuverable.)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (none)
Description : 5/25 points. (empty and boring)

Total : 35/120
(you've worked on maneuverability. But now you need to work on appearance. )


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/2SARf9/BTA
@UmibiSakura
Appearance: 15/30 points. (try a little harder on the look and it'll be awesome)
The plane performs its functions: 15/20 points. (well, it hurts)
Flight characteristics: 15/20 points. (missing the trimmer)
Cool features: 2/25 points. (slightly)
Description : 0/25 points. (no)

Total : 37/120
(looks too easy)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/V1TM95/other-Unusual-design-plane-challenge-plane
@MrPringles
Appearance: 10/30 points. (bad, just bad)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (suddenly, it flies)
Flight characteristics: 15/20 points. (I was able to fly it without the wing.)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (no)
Description : 3/25 points. (empty)

Total : 38/120
(better than your last plane)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/os70M4/Grenton-F-50
@Bonelesspizza.
Appearance: 10/30 points. (unusual, but seen somewhere)
The plane performs its functions: 15/20 points. (Not a bad fighter if you make some adjustments)
Flight characteristics: 15/20 points. (on the verge of stalling, but it did not. Cool. )
Cool features: 2/25 points. (Well, yes, radar. But it is not yours. )
Description : 3/25 points. (it is written a lot.)

Total : 45/120
(Work on the Vitality of the propellers. Sometimes get screwed up when making sudden maneuvers.)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/SByZ0s/Tupolev-Tu-32
@NeinNein
Appearance: 10/30 points. (blocky and angular)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (Sloppy Bomber for a tri-engine)
Flight characteristics: 10/20 points. (tight).
Cool features: 0/25 points. (no)
Description : 15/25 points. (letters!)

Total : 45/120
(this cabin... )


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/q1aAl1/A-Thing
@Ihatenames
Appearance: 15/30 points. (the devil's spawn)
The plane performs its functions: 15/20 points. (suddenly, I win a Dogfight on this one)
Flight Characteristics: 15/20 points. (A little unstable, but it flies)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (no)
Description : 1/25 points. (almost nothing)

Total : 46/120
(I'm sitting here now, laughing my ass off)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/UKg139/Arkhangelski-Ar-3
@SturerEmil
Appearance: 15/30 points. (flying wing? )
The plane performs its functions: 15/20 points. (light bomber)
Flight characteristics: 10/20 points. (tight. But I won't beat it.)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (None)
Description : 7/25 points. (this is the whole story.)

Total : 47/120
(I was able to bomb a convoy on this one.)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/6XKKV1/Dont-ask-fuulidder
@RandomDisplay 
Appearance: 20/30 points. (detailed)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (what do you think a flying car can do)
Flight characteristics: 10/20 points. (difficult)
Cool features: 5/25 points. Full interior view.
Description : 3/25 points. (empty)

Total : 48/120
(wheels and wings control should be separated)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/S967ch/Voughy-V-173-pancake-plane
@EliCandyYT69
Appearance: 20/30 points. (not bad)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (it flies)
Flight characteristics: 10/20 points. (the plane is heavy)
Cool features: 5/25 points. (landing gear)
Description : 4/25 points. (little)

Total : 49/120
(not bad, but a bit simple)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/6TP882/WanderWing-CER-Jumpship
@NoTimeForLaughing
Appearance: 15/30 points. (not catastrophic, but could be better)
The plane performs its functions: 10/20 points. (capable of doing something)
Flight characteristics: 15/20 points. (good maneuverability, but slow).
Cool features: 0/25 points. (got out of the chat room)
Description : 15/25 points. (painted.)

Total : 55/120
(are you sure one landing gear rack is enough?)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/2r13BE/Radeon-S
@RandomDisplay
Appearance: 10/30 points. (looks stoned)
The plane performs its functions: 20/20 points. (fighter from hell)
Flight Characteristics: 20/20 points. (dances like crazy)
Cool features: 7/25 points. (Deflectable vector of thrust.)
Description : 2/25 points. (little, very little. )

Total : 59/120
(pump out his appearance and he will be a fire airplane. )

Top 10 :


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/c20b7A/Dornier-Do-676
@NeinNein
Appearance: 15/30 points. (someone tried)
The plane performs its functions: 15/20 points. (as a bomber, yes)
Flight characteristics: 15/20 points. ( No more than).
Cool features: 0/25 points. (None)
Description : 15/25 points. (work is visible)

Total : 60/120
(good potential)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/9pq510/challenge-entry-K-class-flying-battleship
@Arsenia
Appearance: 20/30 points. (giant, but not very detailed)
The plane performs its functions: 20/20 points. (kills everything and everything)
Flight Characteristics: 10/20 points. (The gyroscope is very annoying.)
Cool features: 0/25 points. (well, none in general)
Description : 15/25 points. (it is written something)

Total : 65/120
(I crashed the game)


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/Gmt8zA/Derp-and-Derper-D16-falcon
@PapaKernels
Appearance: 20/30 points. (black lord)
The plane performs its functions: 15/20 points. (fighter. Good fighter. )
Flight characteristics: 15/20 points. (Flies well).
Cool features: 0/25 points. (None)
Description : 15/25 points. (let him take the bonus already)

Total : 75/120
(F-16 smoker(PapaKernels) )


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/L2udgq/Schloss-Doppelmotor-Ground-Attack-SL-DGA773
@TirpitzWantsPlanes
Appearance: 20/30 points. (cool)
The plane performs its functions: 15/20 points. (Attacker himself)
Flight Characteristics: 10/20 points. (Difficult to fly, but you can fight)
Cool features: 5/25 points. (The landing gear retracts, which is not bad.)
Description : 5/25 points. (with history. )

Total : 75/120
(the pilot will have trouble looking down)

Audience award.


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/45biHE/Ignore-this-SP-community-KCA-Cargo-Boy-Submission-for-challenge
@12705129
Appearance: 20/30 points. (add details and the plane is fire)
The plane performs its functions: 20/20 points. (even so.)
Flight characteristics: 15/20 points. (flies beautifully.)
Cool features: 13/25 points. (for this container, yes!)
Description : 10/25 points. (it's all written down. )

Total : 78/120
(dude! Do it again! )

5-th place

https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/zcC7VF/Mikoyan-Gurevich-MiG-V-Frog
@VibingSovietCat.
Appearance: 25/30 points. (detailed)
The plane performs its functions: 20/20 points. (yes, a good fighter)
Flight characteristics: 15/20 points. (not everything is smooth but it flies well)
Cool features: 10/25 points. (xml missiles and VTOL)
Description : 10/25 points. (hmm... History. )

Total : 80/120
(nice. Level detailing. )

4-th place

https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/gC37iI/YLH-45-51B-unusual-plane-design-challenge-entry
@FlyingTraxxasRustler
Appearance: 25/30 points. (it's wild).
Plane performs its function: 10/20 points. (that's weird)
Flight performance: 15/20 points. (flies pretty good)
Cool performance: 0/25 points. (no)
Description : 10/25 points. (normal written)

Total : 80/120
(I'm quietly hilarious)

3-rd place

https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/R8133d/Amphibian-Interceptor
@MuizTheWeeb.
Appearance: 28/30 points. (epic)
Plane performs its function: 15/20 points. (dangerous opponent)
Flight performance: 10/20 points. (heavy)
Cool performance: 20/25 points. (I'll give you a pat on the back.)
Description : 15/25 points. ()

Total : 88/120.
(beautiful)

2-nd place


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/T4VdBu/XJ-5
@Chinchinory
Appearance: 30/30 points. (frankly cool)
The plane performs its functions: 20/20 points. (very dangerous fighter)
Flight characteristics: 20/20 points. (flies perfectly)
Cool features: 20/25 points. (well, I would like it better.)
Description : 0/25 points. (no)

Total : 90/120
(nice, but the description just killed you.)

1-st place


https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/5xO5zX/MP-2F-Dandelion
@AntiAirNuri.
Appearance: 28/30 points. (beauty)
The plane performs its functions: 20/20 points. (yes, indeed.)
Flight characteristics: 20/20 points. (Flies so cool it is hard to steer)
Cool features: 20/25 points. (just a complete list of what is possible)
Description : 20/25 points. (missing screenshots)

Total : 108/120
(I think the guns are too strong)

  • Log in to leave a comment
  • Profile image

    Boi, 3rd place just like rl

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image

    @Astro12 Gotcha. It's all good! It can spin, especially if you use sudden, full pitch deflections, but I never had any problems testing it out as long as I wasn't reckless. You can also use the flight stability and pitch down when in a spin to recover pretty easily.

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image

    @Astro12 well i made it in 3 minutes so i dont care

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    2,513 Arsenia

    Sorry if my k class crash your game

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    52.8k Astro12

    @PacificRepublic I was able to make it fly. But I couldn't make it fly longer than 10 seconds. It just goes into a spin. That's it.

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image

    I tried my best

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    3,611 Dathcha

    This was fun to read as you roasted a bunch of bronze and white users monstrosities

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image

    Not sure how you couldn't manage to get it to take off haha, I haven't had much issue. It can enter a flat spin, especially with abrupt maneuvers with the flight stability activated but you really have to throw it around for that to happen. Thanks for the competition though, it was a good time building!

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image

    How the hell did I get here?

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image

    @Astro12 Thank you for including mine, although I got a bad score! My 1st ever challenge.

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    2,999 NeinNein

    I didn't expect my monstrosity to get into top 10 lol

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image

    next time you do a challenge, gimme a nice ol tag, i may be interested in perhaps trying to participate

    unless you can't tag me, which is fine and i'll keep my eye out for you posting challenges

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image

    Thank you for 5th!

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    52.8k Astro12

    @12705129 The translator messed up. What I meant was that this design is interesting, and if it is refined a little bit, it will be a masterpiece.

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    5,192 AntiAirNuri

    Fuck yes

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    3,034 12705129

    @Astro12 question- what did you mean by "do it again"? Do a remake of it?

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    3,034 12705129

    I'm surprised I got any sort of place with a plane a built years ago!

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    55.0k PapaKernels

    @Astro12 dang, oh well. could have done better, it was fun tho.

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    52.8k Astro12

    @AntiAirNuri
    I did not take your second plane, because you have already won.

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    52.8k Astro12

    @FlyingTraxxasRustler
    @MuizTheWeeb
    @Chinchinory

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    52.8k Astro12

    @TirpitzWantsPlanes
    @12705129
    @VibingSovietCat

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    52.8k Astro12

    @NoTimeForLaughing
    @Arsenia
    @PapaKernels

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    52.8k Astro12

    @NeinNein
    @RandomDisplay
    @EliCandyYT69

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    52.8k Astro12

    @NavalGunnery
    @UmibiSakura
    @Bonelesspizza

    3.0 years ago
  • Profile image
    52.8k Astro12

    @BigDoot
    @SturerEmil
    @Ihatenames

    3.0 years ago
  • Log in to see more comments