Yesterday my aircraft carrier challenge finished, and I’m now releasing the results. If you catch an error, please let me know.

You can fly the participants’ aircraft here

Results:
F/A 21 @echowhiskey11
Durability: 5/5 I intentionally slammed the thing into the carrier while landing and survived
Range: 4/5 (no comment)
Looks: 4.5/5 very nice design, the nose (in my opinion) is a little wide but overall design is good.
Stability (high spd): 2/5 It pitches up, and trim doesn’t seem to work…
Stability (low spd): 4/5 a little unsteady, but good overall
Replica Points: [None, not a replica]
TOTAL: 19.5

F-32C @falkenwut
Durability: 2/5 did not exactly withstand my rough carrier landings. Lands well on land.
Range: 4/5 (No Comment)
Looks: 4.5/5 Very accurate to the X-32
Stability (high spd): 5/5 stable in flight
Stability (low spd): 3/5 sometimes won’t allow me to climb, or has a lot of ground effect. But stable in flight.
Replica Points: 5/5 Based off of the Boeing X-32 for the JSF program.
+2 for thrust vectoring! Did not know it had it until first takeoff.
TOTAL: 25.5

ROFF 23CA @Mobius1Cyka
Durability: 5/5 It survived my rough carrier landing
Range: 5/5
Looks: 4.5/5 simple design with great capability.
Stability (high spd): 5/5 handles well
Stability (low spd): 5/5 a little wobbly, but stable
Replica Points: (None; not a replica)
TOTAL: 24.5

Aircraft Carrier Challenge @Ethansimmons04
Durability: 3/5 blows up when landing on carrier UNLESS cleavers are removed.
Range: 4/5 when afterburners are on, range is significantly decreased.
Looks: ? “a little rough around the edges, but good” -Qi’ra (Solo; a Star Wars Story)
Stability (high spd): 5/5 handles well
Stability (low spd): 5/5 rather smooth
Replica Points: (not replica)
-2 reason: cockpit is blocked by another part.
TOTAL: 19