Profile image

Recoloring and minor changes Survey

6,971 Puredeath  8.6 years ago

So what are the communities thoughts on recolored planes and planes that only have minor changes done to them compared to their predecessor, being uploaded by other users?

As it stands right now this is allowed, but I have seen a number of planes being reported because they change the color only.

  • Log in to leave a comment
  • Profile image

    @Verdnan : You sound quite smart; I agree. I don't like it when someone earns more points than me with an recoloured airplane I built. But what can we do, indeed it's an open game.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    7,745 tominator

    I don't care much some times I even encourage it. I want to see how you make it.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    27.7k Homersdonut

    I agree with @yeolde1rishman unless its an inappropriate repaint like those cr*p planes

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image

    As long as credit is given

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image

    Jshay made a copy of my Sh-77 but I'm fine with it be has it does look different than mines

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    25.2k JacobHardy64

    @Puredeath I dont really like it. would old ones be kept?

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    6,971 Puredeath

    @Verdnan you can report it and another mod or I will take it down, if we do not catch it first

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    5,514 Verdnan

    What can we do? This has been hit on many times before. No one can really police this sort of thing effectively. Why just a week ago someone uploaded a carbon copy of mine and for what? It's an open game and we have no copyrights, other than not sharing. I'm done with it, I'm done trying to protect my stuff from a small minority that will never succeed in this community. But most people don't, and respect other designers. And it's easy to see who they are. We just have to live with it and try our best to seek out the genuine.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    17.8k jsaret

    I'd say no repaints but I think essentially any other change is perfectly acceptable.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    6,057 Kevpilot

    It fine in my opinion

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    471 Lucky13

    Oh yeah @LordofLego

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    16.2k LordofLego

    I agree with @Lucky13 unless the original was a "replica" with a paint job so incorrect and atrocious that it must be fixed. I haven't seen any yet, though.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    471 Lucky13

    I, personally think that repaint-onlys are abominable

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image

    I'm fine with re-paints but only if they are actually good and not painted in psychedelic colours, I'm also OK with improvements but only if they are credited and improve the realism of a plane, I'm not ok with improvements on FICTIONAL planes because the person improving ususaly takes the full name of the plane, XVI whatsit or something but that pisses me off cause usually they 1. Don't credit u and refer to u as "some guy" 2. Take the name of your plane, suggesting it is the same when no, it's not 3. Fictional planes express our imagination, then someone just takes a dump on your idea when they copy it, 4. Usually they make it worse and 5. Any up votes on that suggest that people like that plane because it has been made worse, therefore they are going against me!

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image

    @HypnoticChicken yes, either make it unlisted or save it to your device in your editor. Either way, I don't think the community really needs to see that sort of content. It doesn't get voted, and it just takes up space on the newest list that could be more original content.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image

    @TheLatentImage I think if u do a repaint, you should have to make it unlisted.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    34.0k AgDynamics

    @TheLatentImage I agree 100%.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image

    For me, recolors don't need to be published publicly. If a user wants a design a specific color or paint scheme then they can paint it and save it. I don't see how multiple colors of the same design benefit the community.

    Design changes, even slight, should stay in my opinion. As long as it is a successor and credit the original, then I personally don't have a problem with it.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    9,173 LT556

    I think it's fine as long as they use the painted tag.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image

    I dislike anything that's a simple repost, it displaces genuine stuff.

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    10.0k iiRazor

    Then why bother report if the predecessor is plagiarized and is a failed attempt? @Puredeath

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    6,971 Puredeath

    @Planeez but generally these successors do not get upvotes

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    10.0k iiRazor

    I mean, both planes and creators benefit from the predecessor...

    8.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    10.0k iiRazor

    I feel that's okay, as long as the changes can easily be seen, such as different wing size/shape, and speed of plane.

    8.6 years ago